Compare
SEO Agency vs Freelancer: Which Is Right for You?
You need SEO help. You've got two options: hire a freelancer or pay an agency. The internet is full of listicles claiming to help you decide, but most are written by agencies trying to sell you agency services, or freelancers dunking on agencies to justify their own existence.
Here's the truth: both can be the right choice. Both can also be a spectacular waste of money. The answer depends on your budget, your goals, the complexity of your site, and how much risk you're willing to take on a single person.
This isn't a sales pitch. Underdog Digital sits somewhere between the two — small enough that you talk directly to the people doing the work, experienced enough to handle complex technical SEO. But this guide isn't about us. It's about helping you make the right call for your situation.
The Real Cost Comparison
Freelancers typically charge $50-$200/hour or $1,000-$5,000/month on retainer. What you get varies wildly. A $75/hour freelancer might be someone who took an SEO course six months ago and is building their portfolio. A $200/hour freelancer might be an ex-agency director with a decade of experience and a roster of enterprise clients.
Agencies start around $3,000/month and go up to $10,000+ for established firms. At $3K, you're usually getting a junior account manager, templatized strategies, and minimal custom work. At $10K+, you might get senior strategists, custom research, and a full team — or you might get the same junior team with a fancier pitch deck. The price doesn't always correlate with quality.
Here's what most people miss: the hourly rate is irrelevant. What matters is the effective cost per unit of useful work. A $200/hour freelancer who audits your site in 4 hours and gives you a prioritized roadmap is cheaper than a $3,000/month agency that takes 3 months to deliver the same thing buried in 60 slides of filler.
Freelancers bill for their time. Agencies bill for access to a team, even if only one person touches your account. If you're paying $5K/month and getting 10 hours of actual work, you're paying $500/hour. Do the math on your current arrangement. You might be surprised.
When a Freelancer Wins
Freelancers are the right choice if you have a small site (under 500 pages), a limited budget (under $3K/month), or a specific one-off project like a site migration, a technical audit, or a content strategy sprint.
They're also the right choice if you value direct access to the person doing the work. When you hire a freelancer, you're hiring their brain, not a process. You get their full attention during your working sessions. No account managers translating your requests. No junior staff misinterpreting strategy. No game of telephone.
Freelancers move fast. They don't need internal approvals or cross-departmental meetings. If you're in a competitive niche and need to execute quickly, a good freelancer will run circles around a traditional agency.
The best freelancers are specialists. A technical SEO freelancer who only does site speed, crawlability, and indexing will know more about those topics than a generalist agency team. A content strategist who only does SEO content will outperform an agency's one-size-fits-all approach.
If your SEO needs are straightforward — fix technical issues, optimize existing pages, build some links — a competent freelancer is probably the most cost-effective option. You don't need a team. You need someone who knows what they're doing and can execute without bureaucracy.
When an Agency Wins
Agencies make sense when you need multiple specialties working together. SEO isn't one skill — it's technical SEO, content, link building, local SEO, analytics, conversion optimization. A freelancer might be strong in two of those areas, passable in one or two more, and weak in the rest. An agency (theoretically) has specialists for each.
They also win when you need scale. If you're publishing 50 blog posts a month, managing local SEO for 100 locations, or building links across 10 different verticals, a freelancer can't handle that volume. You need a team with systems, processes, and enough capacity to execute.
Agencies provide continuity. If your freelancer gets hit by a bus, takes a vacation, or ghosts you for a better client, you're stuck. Agencies have backup. If one person leaves, someone else picks up the account. If someone's on PTO, the work continues. That redundancy costs money, but it reduces risk.
Larger companies often need agencies for political reasons. If you're spending $100K+/year on SEO, your CMO wants a brand-name agency to point to when justifying the budget. A freelancer, no matter how good, doesn't provide that cover. Agencies come with case studies, testimonials, and polished decks that make executives comfortable.
If your SEO needs are complex, ongoing, and require coordination across multiple disciplines, an agency is the safer bet. Just make sure you're getting a real team, not a bait-and-switch where the senior strategist sells you and the junior staff delivers.
The Quality Spectrum for Both
The quality range for freelancers is enormous. The top 10% are ex-agency directors, former in-house leads, or specialists with deep expertise in one area. They charge premium rates, have waitlists, and deliver exceptional work. The bottom 50% are people who learned SEO from YouTube, have never ranked a competitive keyword, and are selling a service they don't fully understand.
The middle 40% are competent generalists. They know the fundamentals, they'll do solid work, but they won't blow your mind. They're fine for small sites with straightforward needs. They're not equipped for complex technical issues or high-stakes competitive niches.
Agencies have the same range, but the distribution is different. The top 10% are legitimately excellent — experienced teams, proven processes, impressive case studies. The bottom 30% are churn-and-burn operations that sell long contracts, deliver generic strategies, and ghost you after 6 months. The middle 60% are fine. Competent but uninspired. They'll move the needle, but slowly.
Here's the problem: it's hard to tell the difference before you hire them. Everyone has a slick website. Everyone claims to be data-driven, results-focused, and client-obsessed. The best signal is referrals from people who've worked with them, ideally in your industry or with similar-sized sites.
One advantage agencies have: you can often meet the team before signing. With freelancers, you're betting on one person's skills, personality, and availability. If they're having a bad quarter, you're having a bad quarter. Agencies smooth out that variance — but they also smooth out the ceiling. The best freelancers are better than the best agency teams. The worst freelancers are worse than the worst agencies.
Red Flags for Both
Freelancer red flags: no portfolio or case studies, rates that are suspiciously low ($30/hour for SEO is a warning sign), vague answers to technical questions, guarantees of specific rankings, unwillingness to get on a call before signing, working on too many clients simultaneously (if they have 20 active retainers, you're not getting focused attention).
Also watch for freelancers who are generalists by necessity, not by choice. If they claim to do SEO, PPC, social media, web design, and copywriting, they're probably mediocre at all of it. Specialists cost more but deliver better results.
Agency red flags: long contracts (12+ months is a trap), no clear point of contact, pitches from senior staff but delivery from juniors, templatized strategies that don't reference your specific site or niche, vague reporting that emphasizes "effort" over results, upselling you on services you don't need.
The biggest red flag for agencies: when you ask who will actually do the work and they deflect. If they won't tell you the name and experience level of the person managing your account, assume it's someone junior. Agencies love to sell you the A-team and deliver the C-team.
For both: beware of anyone who doesn't ask questions. SEO is contextual. If someone pitches you a strategy without understanding your business model, competitors, existing traffic, or technical constraints, they're guessing. Good SEO starts with research, not a canned playbook.
What to Ask Before Hiring
For freelancers: "Can I see examples of sites you've ranked in my niche?" "What does your process look like for the first 30 days?" "How do you handle capacity — what happens if you get busy or take time off?" "What tools do you use, and are those costs included?" "Do you do the work yourself, or do you outsource?"
For agencies: "Who will be my main point of contact, and what's their experience level?" "Can I meet the people who will actually work on my account?" "What does your reporting look like — can I see a sample?" "What happens if my account manager leaves?" "How do you handle underperformance — what's the cancellation process?"
For both: "What would you do differently if this were your site?" This question reveals whether they've actually thought about your situation or are just reciting a script. "What's a project that didn't go well, and what did you learn?" If they claim they've never had a failed project, they're lying.
"How do you prioritize what to work on first?" Good SEO is about leverage — fixing the highest-impact issues first. If they can't articulate a prioritization framework, they're going to waste your time on low-value tasks.
"What should I expect in the first 90 days?" If they promise rankings and traffic immediately, walk away. Real SEO takes time. If they promise vague "optimizations" without specifics, also walk away. You should get a clear roadmap of deliverables, timelines, and expected outcomes.
Finally: "Why shouldn't I hire you?" This is the honesty test. A good freelancer might say "I'm not great at link building — you might need someone else for that." A good agency might say "If you need fast execution, we might be too slow." If they can't name a single downside, they're either overconfident or dishonest.
The Hybrid Option
Some of the best SEO arrangements aren't pure freelancer or pure agency. They're small teams (2-4 people) who work like freelancers but have the capacity of a small agency. Or they're agencies that staff your account with one senior person who does the work themselves, not a team of juniors.
This is where Underdog Digital sits, though we're biased. Small enough that you talk directly to the person doing the work. Experienced enough to handle complex technical SEO, site migrations, and enterprise-level projects. No account managers. No junior staff. No bloated teams billing for meetings.
But we're not the only option. Plenty of ex-agency SEOs have started small firms that operate this way. The key is finding someone who combines the focus of a freelancer with the reliability of an agency.
The downside: these setups are harder to find. They don't scale, so they don't spend money on ads or sales teams. They rely on referrals and word-of-mouth. But if you can find one that's a good fit, it's often the best of both worlds.
If you want to see how we approach SEO, check out our story. If you're curious whether we're a fit, grab a free teardown and we'll audit your site with no obligation.
The Verdict
There's no universal right answer. If you have a small site, a tight budget, and straightforward needs, hire a competent freelancer. If you need multiple specialties, scale, and redundancy, hire a legitimate agency (not a churn-and-burn shop).
The worst decision is hiring based on price alone. The cheapest option is usually the most expensive in the long run. The second-worst decision is hiring based on sales polish. A slick pitch deck doesn't mean good SEO. Results mean good SEO.
Do your homework. Ask for referrals. Talk to multiple options. Ask hard questions. Check their work. If someone's been doing SEO for 10 years and can't show you a single example of a site they've ranked, that tells you everything.
Most importantly: trust your gut. If someone feels slimy, overconfident, or dismissive of your questions, walk away. SEO is a long-term relationship. You're going to be working with this person or team for months, maybe years. Choose someone you actually want to talk to.
Stop Guessing.
Get a Free Teardown.
We'll audit your site and show you exactly what's holding you back.
Get The Teardown